Crumbled up napkin in our vinegar soaked salad . Got us one free drink for a party of 7. Charged us 30 extra for the 8 year olds that didn't eat the food. Ordered 2 steak for 2 meals and both were not cooked to order. One was sent back and still was rare. No salt or seasoning and waitresses had zero personality. We won't be back, not for $406 for 2 steaks for 2, one pasta, 2 appetizers , and 8 drinks ! Very disappointed!!!
Nice place to visit. Relaxing. Fun games at the bar downstairs. Good was good. A little pricey.
ones again like all these great old instructions it changes to much with the new generation who cant seem to leave a good thing alone to bad ......
Great place! Awesome old feel restaurant! Food was on the money! You will not find another restaurant like this in the area!
This place is always awesome. Great steaks perfectly done. Excellent wine list as well. Bring all your friends.
We use to go here back in the 70s with big daddy who knew Sammy very well, it was old style atmosphere wonderful back then, you went to the bar down stairs which was great and always packed, had a shovel board table it was so cool and the steaks and fry's were to die for
Sammy S Ye Old Cider Mill is a US Bar based in Mendham, New Jersey. Sammy S Ye Old Cider Mill is located at 353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham, NJ 07945, USA.
Please contact with Sammy S Ye Old Cider Mill using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Sammy S Ye Old Cider Mill opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.